Cointime

Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

What Is the Best Ethereum Scaling Solution? Part 4: Validium & Volition

What is validium?

Validium is a method of scaling Ethereum that secures the validity of transactions through validity proofs like ZK rollups but does not store or send the transaction data to the Ethereum mainnet. This trade-off of not sending the transaction data to Ethereum allows for massive improvements in scalability where validiums can process about 9,000 transactions per second or more while ZK rollups can process up to about 2,000 transactions per second. Also by not storing transaction data on-chain, transaction information is processed off-chain making them private.

Validium only keeps the validity proofs on-chain and keeps transaction data off-chain.

Due to the technical design of validium, the funds that belong to validium users are controlled by a smart contract on the Ethereum mainnet. Users can withdraw funds by providing Merkle proofs that prove that some of the funds in the smart contract belong to the user. Once the submission is validated, the Merkle proof includes the withdrawal transaction in the validity proofs, thereby processing the withdrawal. Since transaction data is needed to compute Merkle proof, this process also means that user funds can be frozen and restricted from withdrawals if off-chain transaction data is not shared with users.

source: buildblockchain.tech

What is volition?

Since validium, has a lack of on-chain data availability due to not storing and sending transaction data, it is suited for specific use cases like DEXes in DeFi where the number of transactions per second and private infrastructure is important. To reap the benefits of validium with the data availability of rollups, volitions were created by combining a ZK rollup and a validium chain.

Volition allows users to switch between the on-chain data availability of ZK rollups for certain transactions and the off-chain data availability of validium when needed. Users have the freedom to decide how their transactions will be processed according to their circumstances.

What are the shortfallings of validium?

Even though validium allows for magnitudes of transactions compared to different scaling solutions, there are clear weak points.

  1. Limited support for general-purpose applications/smart contracts
  2. Specialized computing language needed for development
  3. The high computational power is required to create ZK proofs that may lead to centralization
  4. Expensive for low throughput applications
  5. Users may have funds frozen or restricted if they do not have access to off-chain data

Validiums/Volitions

Starkware StarkEx

StarkEx is a volition created by Starkware and is built with the Cairo program and SHARP. Depending on specific use cases, users may choose to operate in either ZK Rollup or validium data-availability modes. When used in the validium data-availability mode, all transactions are private and protected by post-quantum secure cryptography. Today, the total value locked in StarkEx is about $508M.

source: Starkware

Matterlabs zkPorter

zkPorter is a volition created by Matterlabs that combines ZK rollups and validium through sharding (read more about sharding HERE). It can support many shards, where the user can choose between off-chain or on-chain data availability, with contracts and accounts being seamlessly interchangeable on either the zkRollup or validium side.

source: Matterlabs

In conclusion:

Validium/Volition is the next step in the innovation of scaling layer 1 chains like Ethereum. Since the overwhelming majority of rollup fees consists of the cost of publishing data onto the Ethereum mainnet, having the transactions kept off-chain allows for cheaper fees and increases throughput. However, this solution comes with a massive trade-off since the off-chain data is not inherently public, users of validium services have an issue of counterparty risk. That is why, due to the design of transaction data not being sent to Ethereum, for security purposes, validium is currently used alongside scaling solutions like zkRollups to make sure users can reap the benefits from both technologies.

We have now explored four mainnet scaling solution: Optimistic rollup, ZK rollup, sidechains, and validium. I hope you had as much fun as me learning about them, their differences, their similarities, and the trade-offs that come with each solution.

Personally, the more I learned about each scaling solution, the more it was difficult for me to pinpoint which is the “best” one. Each scaling solution has distinctive strengths and weaknesses that it is up to the developers to decide which solution is best for the application they are building. However, one thing I can say is that I am more confident about the future of blockchain technology. Its future is in good hands, with driven and intelligent people working to solve the problems blockchain have today and will be continuing to do so in the future.

So what do you think is the best scaling solution for Ethereum?

Ethereum
Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • US Official: Ukraine Agrees to Avoid Strikes on Non-Russian Tankers and Black Sea Oil Facilities

    On August 8, according to a US official, Ukraine has agreed not to target certain non-Russian tankers and Black Sea infrastructure vital to Kazakhstan's crude oil exports. This follows ship attacks last month that caused loading disruptions. The US official said Ukraine has set up contact points so commercial shipping companies can communicate information and ensure safe passage. The commitment was reached after meetings between senior US government leaders and Ukrainian leadership, marking a potentially significant step toward increasing regional oil shipments. Previously, activity in the region had cooled significantly due to several recent attacks near the Caspian Pipeline Consortium terminal in Russia's Novorossiysk. (Jin Shi)

  • U.S. July Nonfarm Payrolls Fall by 23,000, Missing Market Expectations

    On August 7, U.S. nonfarm payrolls decreased by 23,000 in July, compared with market expectations of an increase of 80,000, and the previous value was an increase of 57,000.

  • US May and June Nonfarm Payroll Additions Revised Down by 103,000 Combined

    On August 7, the US Bureau of Labor Statistics: May nonfarm payroll additions were revised down from 129,000 to 63,000; June nonfarm payroll additions were revised down from 57,000 to 20,000. After the revisions, the combined additions for May and June were 103,000 lower than previously reported.

  • U.S. Rate Futures Market Sees Lower Odds of Fed September Hike

    On August 7, the probability of a Fed rate hike in September as priced by U.S. interest rate futures declined.

  • New York Gold Futures Top $4,400 per Ounce

    New York gold futures topped $4,400 per ounce, up 2.36% on the day.

  • Japan Finance Minister: FX Market Affected by Moves Not Driven by Actual Demand

    Japanese Finance Minister Satsuki Katayama said she and U.S. Treasury Secretary Bessent agreed that the foreign exchange market has been affected by moves not driven by actual demand.

  • BTC Breaks Through $65,000

    Market data shows BTC has broken through $65,000, currently reported at $65,007.44, with a 24-hour increase of 0.6%. The market is highly volatile, please exercise risk control.

  • Brent Crude Drops 2.00% Intraday to $81.07/Barrel

    Brent crude oil fell 2.00% during the day, now at $81.07 per barrel. (Jin Shi)

  • Trump: Data Centers May Be More Important Than Oil

    August 7 news, U.S. President Trump said in an interview with Punchbowl News, "I saw the other day that Texas seems to be opposed to building data centers. I think that's a mistake. I'm not taking a position—I just think it's a mistake, because there are other communities that want to build data centers. When a community is willing to accept data centers, it means a lot of money will flow into that community. I don't think they're ugly. Some of the data centers I've seen are the most incredible buildings I've ever seen. They are very important to the economy. If Texas says no to data centers, that's a mistake, because data centers may be more important than oil."

  • Trump to Meet with Mining Executives

    On August 7, according to CCTV International News, US President Trump will convene executives from some of the world's largest mining companies at the US State Department on August 7 local time, in an effort to take action to 'secure critical mineral supplies for the US and its allies.' Reuters reported that the US urgently needs critical minerals to replenish weapons inventories depleted during the war against Iran. During the more than five-month war with Iran, the US military expended large quantities of precision-guided missiles and air defense interceptors. US defense officials and lawmakers have warned that given existing production capacity constraints, replenishing some stockpiles could take years—although the Trump administration has denied reports of a so-called 'severe shortage of ammunition stockpiles.' According to Pentagon officials and defense companies, supplies of minerals such as rare earths, tungsten, germanium, and scandium are essential for manufacturing precision-guided missiles, fighter jets, armored vehicles, infrared sensors, and other advanced weapons systems. Expected attendees include industry giants such as global mining giant Rio Tinto Group, Australia's BHP, US Freeport-McMoRan, US Mountain Pass Materials, US Rare Earths, US Energy Fuels, and Canada's Metals Company. According to sources, the Trump administration plans to announce multiple deals and memorandums of understanding.

Daily Must-Read

Popular Activities

RaveDAO at Terra Solis by Tomorrowland: A Female-Led Techno Night Where Web3 Culture Converges

RaveDAO at Terra Solis by Tomorrowland: A Female-Led Techno Night Where Web3 Culture Converges

April 30 - April 30
Dubai

Popular Tags

Cointime
News
Contents
RSS
Company