Cointime

Download App
iOS & Android

PCAOB Warns Investors Not to Trust Third-Party Verification or Proof-of-Reserves Reports

Cointime Official

Public Company Accounting Oversight Board(PCAOB), an industry-funded watchdog working under the authority of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, warns investors not to trust third-party verification or Proof-of-reserves reports, according to a press release.

"Proof of reserve reports are inherently limited, and customers should exercise extreme caution when relying on them to conclude that there are sufficient assets to meet customer liabilities." PCAOB wrote in the statement.

"...investors should note that PoR engagements are not audits and, consequently, the related reports do not provide any meaningful assurance to investors or the public." PCAOB added.

As per the PCAOB, these asset verifications only provide a basic snapshot and fail to take into account the crypto entity's liabilities, the digital asset holders' rights and responsibilities, or whether the assets were borrowed by the entity to fabricate adequate collateral. It's important to note that these documents do not demonstrate anything about a company's internal controls or governance, as stated by the board.
PCAOB pointed out that it's important to note PoR (Proof of Reserves) Reports are not on par with, nor more thorough than, an audit, and they do not comply with PCAOB auditing standards. Moreover, there is a lack of consistency in terms of the service providers that carry out PoR engagements. While some accounting firms handle these engagements, others are managed by non-accountant assurance providers. Furthermore, the crypto entity's management retains the freedom to decide whether or not to disclose the outcomes of PoR reports, including the scope and structure of the information disclosed.

SEC
Comments

All Comments

Recommended for you

  • Israel Actively Prepares to Resume War Against Iran

    On April 25, according to CCTV International News, in the context of stalled substantive progress in US-Iran negotiations, Israel has been intensifying preparations to restart the war. Israeli media analysis suggests that Israel has not fully achieved its set war objectives. Since the temporary ceasefire, Israel's substantial military readiness expansion has never ceased, including replenishing weapons and ammunition, updating its list of targets for strikes against Iran, and formulating joint military plans with the US military. Once the US decides to resume military actions, Israel will ensure it can respond immediately.

  • NVIDIA's Market Value Surpasses $5 Trillion Again

    On April 24, NVIDIA's stock price rose by 3.08%, reaching $205.790 per share, with a total market value of $5.00 trillion. The stock price hit a new high since late October 2025.

  • Ethereum Foundation to Sell 10,000 ETH to BitMine

    On April 24, the Ethereum Foundation announced the finalization of a sale of 10,000 ETH to BitMine, the first treasury company of Ethereum, through an over-the-counter (OTC) trading platform, at an average price of $2,387 per ETH.

  • Sources: U.S. Justice Department Expected to Drop Criminal Investigation into Powell

    On April 24, multiple informed sources revealed that the U.S. Justice Department is expected to conclude its criminal investigation into Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell as early as Friday, thereby ending a stalemate that could have delayed the appointment of Powell's successor. Sources indicated that senior officials from the Justice Department recently contacted several senators, including Republican Senator Thom Tillis, a member of the Senate Banking Committee, to inform them of the plan to abandon the investigation into alleged cost overruns related to the renovation of the Federal Reserve's Washington headquarters, and to refer the matter to the Federal Reserve's internal oversight body. Powell's term is set to end next month, but he stated in March that he would remain until Trump's nominee for Federal Reserve Chair, Waller, is confirmed. (ABC News)

  • U.S. Stock Indices Open Higher; Intel Surges Approximately 23% to Record High

    On April 24, U.S. stock indices opened higher across the board, with the Dow Jones up 0.02%, the S&P 500 rising 0.4%, and the Nasdaq increasing by 0.73%. Intel surged approximately 23%, reaching a record high; the company expects second-quarter revenue between $13.8 billion and $14.8 billion, while the market estimate is $13.04 billion. AMD rose over 10%, and Arm increased more than 8%. Nvidia's stock price rose by 0.11%, while Google's Class A shares fell by 0.49%. Apple's stock price decreased by 0.61%, Microsoft’s stock rose by 0.47%, Amazon's stock increased by 1.42%, Meta Platforms Inc Class A shares fell by 0.34%, Tesla's stock remained unchanged, and Netflix's stock dropped by 0.92%.

  • BTC Surpasses $78,000

    Market data shows that BTC has surpassed $78,000, currently priced at $78,013.14, with a 24-hour increase of 0.7%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • Central Bank and Eight Departments: Prohibit Online Marketing Services for Virtual Currency Issuance and Trading

    On April 24, the People's Bank of China and eight other departments jointly issued the "Regulations on the Management of Online Marketing of Financial Products," which will take effect on September 30, 2026, systematically regulating online marketing activities for financial products. The regulations specify that only approved financial institutions and their self-operated platforms, as well as entrusted third-party internet platforms, may engage in online marketing of financial products. It prohibits providing online marketing services for illegal financial activities such as illegal fundraising, virtual currency issuance and trading, and illegal foreign exchange margin trading. The regulations detail requirements regarding the authenticity of marketing content, risk disclosure, algorithm recommendations, pop-up advertisements, account naming, trademark usage, cooperation models, and the protection of data and personal information. They also clarify the regulatory responsibilities and penalties for financial management departments, internet information, telecommunications, and market supervision departments.

  • BTC Surpasses $78,000

    Market data shows that BTC has surpassed $78,000, currently priced at $78,049.83, with a 24-hour increase of 0.04%. The market is experiencing significant volatility, so please ensure proper risk management.

  • DeepSeek-V4 Preview Version Officially Launched and Open-Sourced

    On April 24, DeepSeek announced via its official WeChat account that the preview version of the new model series DeepSeek-V4 is officially online and open-sourced. DeepSeek-V4 features a million-word ultra-long context and leads in agent capabilities, world knowledge, and reasoning performance in both domestic and open-source fields. The model is available in two versions based on size. Starting today, users can log in to the official website chat.deepseek.com or the official app to interact with the latest DeepSeek-V4 and explore the new experience of 1M ultra-long context memory. The API service has also been updated; by changing the model_name to deepseek-v4-pro or deepseek-v4-flash, users can access it.

  • Intel CEO: Semiconductor Potential Market Size Approaching $1 Trillion

    On April 24, local time, after the U.S. stock market closed on April 23, Intel officially released its Q1 fiscal year 2026 financial report and held an earnings call. The company delivered its sixth consecutive quarter of better-than-expected results, with revenue, gross margin, and earnings per share all surpassing guidance. The AI business has become the core growth engine, with a surge in demand for server CPUs and advancements in advanced processes and packaging exceeding expectations. Following this financial report, Intel's stock price surged nearly 20% in after-hours trading. During the earnings call, Intel CEO Pat Gelsinger stated that despite continuous improvements in factory capacity, demand across all business segments remains higher than supply, particularly for Xeon server CPUs, which are expected to maintain strong growth momentum over the next two years. Gelsinger also noted, 'In recent years, the focus in high-performance computing has been almost entirely on graphics processors and other accelerators. In recent months, clear signs have shown that central processing units are becoming an indispensable foundation in the era of artificial intelligence.' Looking at the overall market, Gelsinger anticipates that driven by explosive growth in AI demand, the overall potential market size of the semiconductor industry is approaching $1 trillion. However, Intel's management also warned that the company still faces multiple pressures, including declining demand in the PC market, rising costs, expanding capital expenditures, and supply constraints. (Dongxin News Agency)